Canada's PM Stephen Harper faces revolt by scientists
The Guardian
July 9, 2012
Canada's prime minister, Stephen Harper, faces a widening revolt by the country's leading scientists against sweeping cuts to government research labs and broadly pro-industry policies.
The scientists plan to march through Ottawa in white lab coats on Tuesday in the second big protest in a month against the Harper government's science and environmental agenda.
Harper is accused of pushing through a slew of policies weakening or abolishing environmental protections – with an aim of expanding development of natural resources such as the Alberta tar sands.
His government is also accused of jeopardising Canada's scientific reputation by shutting down the Experimental Lakes Area (ELA), a research station that produced critical evidence to help stop acid rain.
"In my view there are a lot of attempts in this country, and other countries too, to push through resource-based economies," said Prof John Smol, a freshwater lake biologist at Queen's University in Kingston, Ontario. "People working at ELA are constantly finding reasons why you can't just put a pipeline here, or an industry there, because there are going to be environmental costs."
Andrew Weaver, a climate scientist at the University of Victoria in British Columbia, was even more pointed. "It's not about saving money. It's about imposing ideology," he said. "What's happening here is that the government has an ideological agenda to develop the Canadian economy based on the extraction of oil out of the Alberta tar sands as quickly as possible and sell it as fast as it can, come hell and high water, and eliminate any barriers that stand in their way."
However, a spokeswoman for Gary Goodyear, the minister of state for science and technology, said the government remained committed to funding science. "Our government has made historic investments in science, technology and research to create jobs, grow our economy, and improve the quality of life for Canadians," she said.
But Canadian government officials also indirectly confirmed scientists' charges that Harper was far more interested in funding research with direct industry applications, than in funding pure science or environmental research.
Read the full story in the Guardian.
Read related stories:
- Calgary Herald; August 19, 2012; "Former DFO officer says Stephen Harper 'disembowelled science behind Enbridge pipeline"
- CBC; July 10, 2012; "Death of scientific evidence mourned on Parliament Hill"
- Guardian; July 2, 2012; "Oh Canada: the government's broad assault on the environment"
- Chronicle Herald; June 27, 2012; "Ottawa axes fisheries staff, offices"
- Canada.com; June 26, 2012; "Budget offers new tools to "authorize" water pollution, says Harper minister"
- Globe and Mail; June 22, 2012; "Ex-Fisheries directors urge Harper to reverse freshwater-research cuts"
- CBC; June 22, 2012; "Fisheries changes attacked in prestigious Science journal"
- CTV News; June 22, 2012; "B.C. scientists blast Fisheries Act changes in journal"
- Surrey Leader; June 19, 2012; "Greens decry passage of contentious federal bill"
- Vancouver Sun; June 12, 2012; "More debate needed on Tories' Bill C-38"
- Times Colonist; May 31, 2012; "Ex-ministers press Harper on fisheries plans"
- Globe and Mail; May 28, 2012; "Four former ministers protest ‘taking the guts out’ of Fisheries Act"
- Globe and Mail; May 28, 2012; "Opposition aims to disrupt passage of omnibus Tory budget bill"
- Vancouver Sun; May 15, 2012; "Omnibus bill threatens fish: Cummins"
- CBC; May 3, 2012; "Budget bill makes complex changes to fisheries protection"
- Vancouver Sun; May 1, 2012; "Fisheries Act changes introduced amid debate over new law's intent"
- Vancouver Sun; April 27, 2012; "Fisheries Act changes introduced amid debate over new law's intent"
- FIS; April 25, 2012; "Govt to help protect commercial fisheries"
- Agassiz-Harrison Observer; April 17, 2012; "Valley farmers protest heavy-handed measures to protect fish"
- Vancouver Sun; April 8, 2012; "Metro Vancouver wants proposed changes to Fisheries Act reeled in"
- Surrey Leader; April 5, 2012; "Metro Vancouver opposes any weakening of fish habitat rules"
- Campbell River Mirror; April 3, 2012; "Controversial Fisheries Act changes don’t make federal budget cut"
- Boundary Sentinel; March 31, 2012; "A Bad Week for the Environment"
- Comox Valley Local News; March 30, 2012; "Fish habitats survive Federal Budget"
- CBC News; March 29, 2012; "Scientists worried about proposed fish habitat changes"
- Chilliwack Times; March 27, 2012; "Protection for fish may be lost"
- Nanaimo Daily News; March 26, 2012; "Feds should listen to critics"
- Telegraph Journal; March 26, 2012; "Fisheries Act changes could affect wild salmon"
- FIS; March 26, 2012; "Scientists push against changes to the Fisheries Act"
- The Tyee; March 24, 2012; "Don't gut Fisheries Act, plead 625 scientsts"
- The Kingston Whig Standard, March 24, 2012; "Something fishy"
- Burnaby Now; March 23, 2012; "Scientists rally to save fish habitat"
- Vancouver Sun; March 23, 2012; "Scientists pressure PM over Fisheries Act - 'Weakening habitat protection' would make Canada look irresponsibly, Ecology professor says"
- Edmonton Journal; March 23, 2012; "Don't water down Fisheries Act, scientists urge"
- Chronicle Herald; March 23, 2012; "Don't remove habitat protection, fisheries scientists urge Ottawa"
- Campbell River Courier; March 23, 2012; "Ducking Duncan being criticized for being MIA"
- The Telegram; March 23, 2012; "Opposition grows to possible Fisheries Act changes"
- Vancouver Sun, March 22, 2012; "Pressure mounts against changes to Fisheries Act"
- CBC News; March 22, 2012; "Don't ease fish protection rules, PM urged"
- Ottawa Citizen; March 22, 2012; "Ottawa Riverkeeper calls for public consultations on Fisheries Act"
- Globe and Mail, March 22, 2012; "Don't gut Fisheries Act, scientists urge Harper"
- Toronto Star; March 22, 2012; "Noted scientists warn Stephen Harper against Fisheries Act changes"
- The Nelson Daily, March 22, 2012; "Local MP criticizes Fed plans to gut Fisheries Act"
- The Telegram; March 22, 2012; "Wave of opposition to possible Fisheries Act changes"
- The Record; March 22, 2012; "Scientists speak against possible Fisheries Act changes"
- Globe and Mail; March 22, 2012; "Ottawa wants to bow out of regulating fish habitat documents show"
- The Western Star; March 22, 2012; "Former DFO biologist, local anglers group worried about habitat protection laws"
- Vancouver Sun; March 22, 2012; "Don't water down Fisheries Act, scientists urge Haper in letter"
- Edmonton Journal; March 21, 2012; "Second former Tory minister blasts plan for Fisheries Act - Removing reference to habitat protection would be a ‘very serious error,’ John Fraser says"
- Globe and Mail; March 21, 2012; "Fish habitat:Why rock the boat?"
- Times Colonist; March 21, 2012; "Discussion needed in fisheries changes"
- Vancouver Sun; March 21, 2012; "Fisheries plan draws more heat from right"
- Vancouver Sun; March 20, 2012; "Scientists sour on plan to alter act"
- Montreal Gazette; March 20, 2012; "Second former fisheries minister rips reported changes to Fisheries Act"
- Globe and Mail; March 17, 2012; "Critics of Fisheries Act cahnges fear lasting legacy"
- Vancouver Sun; March 15, 2012; "Changes to Fisheries Act would be 'death blow,' Greens warn"
- Times Colonist; March 15, 2012; "Harper changes the rules for the environment"
- Lake Country Calendar; March 15, 2012; "Biologist claims fedaral Fisheries Act about to be gutted"
- Chronicle Herald; March 14, 2012; "Feds 'neutering' Fisheries Act"
- Vancouver Sun, March 13, 2012; "Canada poised to roll back fish protection laws, biologist claims"
- Globe and Mail; March 13, 2012; "Ottawa wants to bow out of regulating fish habitat, documents show"
Posted July 9th, 2012